News

Danish Court Rules Apple Must Replace Man's iPhone With New Rather Than Refurbished Model

2016-12-12 1807 Posted by Reposted

A court in Denmark today ruled Apple must replace a Danish man's iPhone with a new model rather than a refurbished model in accordance with local law. 


Danish Court Rules Apple Must Replace Man's iPhone With New Rather Than Refurbished Model


A trio of judges found Apple was not entitled to replace David Lysgaard's iPhone 4 with a refurbished model since it may contain recycled parts, which could result in a lower resale value and went against his "legitimate expectation" of receiving a brand new iPhone equivalent to his original purchase. 

By providing Lysgaard with a refurbished iPhone, rather than an equivalent new model, the court found Apple to have violated the Danish Sale of Goods Act. The judges upheld an earlier decision reached by Denmark's Consumer Complaints Board, which also said the replacement should be a new, not refurbished, model. 

Apple disagreed with the Consumer Complaints Board's decision in 2014 and sued Lysgaard, arguing that refurbished iPhones are produced and tested in the same way as new iPhones. Apple also said refurbished iPhones undergo rigorous tests and strict quality control. Apple can now appeal the judgment with a higher court. 

Earlier this year, a Dutch court 
similarly ordered Apple to replace a woman's iPhone 6 Plus with a new model, not a refurbished one.


Source: MacRumors

Related Articles

Apple Removes iCloud Activation Lock Status Tool From Website macOS High Sierra 10.13.2 Beta 4 Now Available Apple Releases macOS Catalina With Find My, Screen Time, and No More iTunes Rumor: Apple Blocks Activation on iOS 9.0-9.3.5 Firmware Apple Still Signing iOS 11.3 Beta 5/6, Downgrade to It to Jailbreak Your iPhone iOS 10.3 Jailbreak / iOS 10.3.1 Jailbreak How to Download Apple’s Official iOS IPSW with One Simple Step? Backup Your iOS Device When It's Disabled or in Password in Normal Mode