Florida Court Dismisses Lawsuit Alleging Apple Intentionally ‘Broke’ FaceTime on Older iPhones
Apple has come across a small victory in Florida this week, with a federal court tossing out a lawsuit claiming the company intentionally broke FaceTime for users of older iPhone models. The lawsuit specifically alleged Apple broke FaceTime “to avoid costly transmitting services.”
Back in 2017, Apple was hit with a class action lawsuit in California claiming it intentionally broke FaceTime for users of older iPhones and iPads. A similar lawsuit emerged last August in Florida, again accusing Apple of breaking FaceTime on devices running iOS 6 and earlier.
And in February, Apple agreed to settle the lawsuit in California. But meanwhile, a federal court in Florida has ruled today that the claims “are untimely and must be dismissed,” Bloomberg Law says. So while Apple has agreed to settle the lawsuit in California, it’s now off the hook in Florida.
Both the Florida and the California lawsuits centered on the idea that Apple rendered FaceTime useless for people using devices on iOS 6, primarily to avoid paying increasingly high data costs to Akamai.
As we explained: When FaceTime originally launched, there were two technologies used for connecting iPhones together. The first used a peer-to-peer standard to directly transfer audio and video between users. The other used a “relay method,” relying on third-party servers from Akami to transfer the data between users.
Come 2012, however, Apple was found guilty of violating patents owned by VirnetX with its peer-to-peer tech, thus forcing the company to switch to the relay method for all FaceTime calls and data.
These changes prompted Apple to investigate ways to reduce the cost of FaceTime, thus leading to the development of a new peer-to-peer standard that didn’t infringe on VirnetX patents. The new technology debuted with iOS 7, but the lawsuits alleged that Apple realized it could force people to either upgrade to iOS 7 or break FaceTime on iOS 6 by causing an important digital certificate to expire earlier.
- New iOS 11 Concept Video Shows Night Mode, Group FaceTime Calls & More iOS 12 Highlights: Memoji, Tech Addiction Tool, Group FaceTime Tencent Security Release FaceTime Video Fraud Warning: Do Not Accept the Invitation iOS 11 to Bring Group FaceTime Video Calling? Analytics Show iOS 11 Now Installed on 47% of Devices Apple’s Use of ‘Face ID’ Could Result in a Lawsuit Apple Negotiating with United Arab Emirates Government to Lift Ban on FaceTime iMac Pro Debuts Custom Apple T2 Chip to Handle Secure Boot, Password Encryption